Low on paper, and the published numbers need care. USCIS posts a table of AAO appeal decisions on the merits for its most common case types, FY2022 through FY2026. Across every case type in that table, the AAO decided 2,917 appeals on the merits in FY2026: 2,493 dismissed, 40 sustained, and 384 remanded. By our calculation, sustained appeals were 1.4% of those decisions and remands 13.2%. In FY2025 the same table shows 2,878 merit decisions: 2,181 dismissed, 118 sustained (4.1%), and 579 remanded (20.1%) (USCIS data accessed November 3, 2026). For extraordinary ability I-140s (EB-1A), the AAO dismissed 348, sustained 2, and remanded 71 in FY2026, against 318, 5, and 69 in FY2025.
Three limits on those numbers. A remand is not an approval: it sends the case back to the office that decided it for a new decision. The table leaves out motions, certifications, rejections, summary dismissals, and withdrawals. And it does not count appeals the deciding office grants itself during its initial review. USCIS says that "[w]hile specific data are not currently available, a significant number of appeals are favorably resolved during initial field review."
None of this is your odds. The outcome turns on what the denial got wrong and what the record can show, which is why the choice among a motion, an appeal, and a lawsuit matters more than any average.