Skip to main content

Form I-290B: Motions and AAO Appeals Before Court

Motions and AAO appeals are the administrative routes after a denial; they are faster and cheaper than a lawsuit, sometimes required to build the record, and for most petitions are not a prerequisite to suing.

Deadline: 30 days to appeal or file a motion (33 if mailed)

You have 30 days. To appeal to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) or file a motion to reopen or reconsider, file Form I-290B within 30 days of the decision. If USCIS mailed the decision, add 3 days, for 33. There is no 90-day window to appeal.

The clock starts on the date USCIS mailed the decision, not the day it reached you, and USCIS must receive your filing by the deadline. The extra 3 days apply only to decisions served by mail. If the decision was delivered only to your USCIS online account, plan on 30.

Revocations are shorter. An appeal of a decision revoking an approved immigrant petition under 8 C.F.R. § 205.2 is due in 15 days, or 18 if the revocation was mailed.

Late filings. USCIS rejects a late appeal, but if it meets the motion requirements it is treated as a motion, and the office that decided the case must decide it on the merits. A late motion to reopen is accepted only if you show the delay was reasonable and beyond your control.

Rules: 8 C.F.R. §§ 103.3(a)(2)(i) (appeals), 103.5(a)(1)(i) (motions), 103.8(b) (3 days added for mail), and 205.2(d) (revocations); Form I-290B instructions.

What is Form I-290B?

Form I-290B, Notice of Appeal or Motion, is the USCIS form you use to challenge an unfavorable USCIS decision without going to court. One form does one of two things: it files an appeal with the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO), or it files a motion with the USCIS office that issued the latest decision in your case, which can be a field office, a service center, or the AAO itself.

Generally only the applicant or petitioner can file it, not the beneficiary. For a self-petition such as the EB-1A or the national interest waiver, you are the petitioner, so you can. A beneficiary of a revoked I-140 can file when USCIS has said so in the revocation notice. You cannot file an appeal and a motion on the same form: you file a separate I-290B, with its own fee, for each. A combined motion to reopen and reconsider counts as one motion.

The I-290B does not reach every decision. Appeals of a family-based I-130, for example, go to the Board of Immigration Appeals on a different form, and some denials can be challenged only by motion. USCIS lists which forms can be appealed and which only allow a motion on its "When to Use Form I-290B" page.

What is the I-290B filing fee?

The I-290B filing fee is $800 (as of November 3, 2026). It is the same for an appeal and for a motion, and it is set by regulation, 8 C.F.R. § 106.2(a)(16), and listed in USCIS's fee schedule, Form G-1055 (edition 10/26/26). The $800 fee has been in the regulation since April 1, 2024, the effective date of USCIS's 2024 fee rule (89 FR 6194), and the fee schedule we checked shows no later change for the I-290B.

Each I-290B takes its own fee, so an appeal and a separate motion cost $1,600. Some filers pay nothing: the fee schedule exempts, among others, certain VAWA, T, U, and Special Immigrant Juvenile filers, and some applicants can request a fee waiver on Form I-912. An employment-based petitioner should plan on the full fee. USCIS rejects a filing with the wrong fee.

Where and how do you file Form I-290B?

By mail, to the USCIS lockbox address listed for your type of decision on USCIS's "Direct Filing Addresses for Form I-290B" page. Form I-290B is not on USCIS's list of forms that can be filed online, and USCIS says not to send it to the AAO directly, even when you are appealing to the AAO.

USCIS changed the I-290B filing addresses on October 7, 2026. Check the addresses page on the day you mail; an old address from a past filing or another website may no longer be right (as of November 3, 2026).

USCIS rejects an unsigned form, a form on the wrong edition or with the wrong fee, and a form missing required fields in Part 1; it may also reject one with more than one box checked in Part 2. An appeal has to address every ground of ineligibility in the decision; the form warns that a ground you do not address may be treated as waived. On an appeal you can attach your brief and evidence or send them to the AAO within 30 calendar days of filing. A motion is different: the brief and evidence go in with the motion.

How long does an I-290B take?

An appeal is not sent straight to the AAO. The office that made the decision reviews it first and, within 45 days of receiving it, may treat it as a motion and approve the case itself (8 C.F.R. § 103.3(a)(2)(iii)). If it does not, it forwards the appeal and the record to the AAO.

The AAO's goal is to decide an appeal within 180 days of receiving a complete record. On its processing-times page (last updated October 5, 2026; checked November 3, 2026), it reports that in July–September 2026 (FY2026 Q4) it completed 80.6% of its 780 decisions (appeals and motions) within 180 days. For extraordinary ability I-140s (EB-1A) the figure was 97.4% of 155 decisions, and for national interest waiver I-140s it was 99.3% of 141. Those 180 days run from when the AAO receives the record, so add the time the deciding office holds the appeal first.

A motion is decided by the office that issued the decision, and the AAO's figures cover only the AAO's own decisions. USCIS does not publish a separate processing time for motions on the AAO page; check the case processing times tool for the office that decided your case.

What are the odds of winning an I-290B appeal?

Low on paper, and the published numbers need care. USCIS posts a table of AAO appeal decisions on the merits for its most common case types, FY2022 through FY2026. Across every case type in that table, the AAO decided 2,917 appeals on the merits in FY2026: 2,493 dismissed, 40 sustained, and 384 remanded. By our calculation, sustained appeals were 1.4% of those decisions and remands 13.2%. In FY2025 the same table shows 2,878 merit decisions: 2,181 dismissed, 118 sustained (4.1%), and 579 remanded (20.1%) (USCIS data accessed November 3, 2026). For extraordinary ability I-140s (EB-1A), the AAO dismissed 348, sustained 2, and remanded 71 in FY2026, against 318, 5, and 69 in FY2025.

Three limits on those numbers. A remand is not an approval: it sends the case back to the office that decided it for a new decision. The table leaves out motions, certifications, rejections, summary dismissals, and withdrawals. And it does not count appeals the deciding office grants itself during its initial review. USCIS says that "[w]hile specific data are not currently available, a significant number of appeals are favorably resolved during initial field review."

None of this is your odds. The outcome turns on what the denial got wrong and what the record can show, which is why the choice among a motion, an appeal, and a lawsuit matters more than any average.

Motion to reopen vs. motion to reconsider vs. AAO appeal

All three are filed on the same Form I-290B, with the same $800 fee and the same 30-day deadline (33 days if the decision was mailed). They differ in what you must show and who decides.

Sources: 8 C.F.R. §§ 103.3, 103.5, 103.8(b); Form I-290B and its instructions (checked November 3, 2026).
Motion to reopenMotion to reconsiderAAO appeal
What you must showNew facts, supported by affidavits or other documentary evidence (§ 103.5(a)(2))That the decision misapplied law or USCIS policy, judged on the record when it was decided (§ 103.5(a)(3))An erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact in the decision, addressing every ground of denial
New evidence?Yes, that is the point of itNoYes, with the appeal or sent to the AAO within 30 days of filing
Who decidesThe office that issued the decisionThe office that issued the decisionThe deciding office reviews first (up to 45 days, and may approve); then the AAO
Deadline30 days; 33 if mailed. A late filing may be excused only if the delay was reasonable and beyond your control30 days; 33 if mailed30 days; 33 if mailed. 15 days (18 if mailed) for a § 205.2 revocation
Fee$800$800$800

When to go to federal court instead

For most employment-based petitions an AAO appeal is optional, so a lawsuit does not have to wait for one (the legal framework below explains why, and the EB-5 exception). Court is usually the better forum when the denial rests on a clear legal error, the record is already complete, and another round inside the agency would add months without a neutral decision-maker. A court reviews the record USCIS had; it does not take new evidence, so a case that needs new evidence belongs in a motion to reopen or an appeal first.

If the problem is not a denial but a petition that USCIS has not decided at all, the remedy is a mandamus or unreasonable-delay suit rather than an I-290B.

What This Is

When this comes up

A petition was denied and you are deciding what comes next. Before a federal lawsuit is even on the table, USCIS offers three in-agency paths: a motion to reopen, a motion to reconsider, and an appeal to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on Form I-290B. These are the ordinary first responses to a denial, and for many cases they are the right one.

These administrative paths and federal litigation are not either/or — they are a sequence, and how they fit together is itself a strategic decision. A motion or appeal is faster and far cheaper than a lawsuit, it can add evidence a court never could, and a well-built appeal record makes a later APA suit stronger if it comes to that. For most employment-based petitions, though, an AAO appeal is not required before you can sue.

The mechanics of these three paths — the exact standards, deadlines, and how to choose between them — are laid out in detail on our EB-1A post-denial page. This page focuses on how they relate to litigation: when to work inside the agency first, and when to go straight to court.

The Legal Framework

What the law provides

Motions go back to the office that denied the case, under 8 C.F.R. § 103.5. A motion to reopen must state new facts supported by documentary evidence (§ 103.5(a)(2)); a motion to reconsider must show the decision was based on an incorrect application of law or policy on the record as it stood (§ 103.5(a)(3)). The two match different defects: reopen is for new evidence, reconsider is for legal error — and they can be filed together.

An appeal goes to the AAO under 8 C.F.R. § 103.3, also on Form I-290B. The AAO reviews de novo — law, fact, policy, and discretion — and, unlike a motion to reconsider, it accepts new evidence. That breadth is a double-edged sword: the AAO can also affirm a denial on a ground the service center never reached, and it can re-examine a criterion the original officer conceded.

The deadlines are short and unforgiving. A motion or appeal must be filed within 30 days of the decision — 33 if the decision was served by mail (8 C.F.R. § 103.8(b)) — with a shorter window, 15 days (18 if mailed), to appeal the revocation of an already-approved immigrant petition (8 C.F.R. § 205.2(d)). These clocks are the opposite of the six-year window for an APA suit, so preserving the administrative options is a time-sensitive decision even when litigation is the likely endgame.

For most employment-based petitions, exhausting the AAO is not a prerequisite to federal court. The Supreme Court held in Darby v. Cisneros, 509 U.S. 137 (1993), that courts may not require a plaintiff to pursue an optional administrative appeal before APA review unless a statute or regulation both mandates the appeal and makes the decision inoperative while it is pending. The USCIS appeal regulation does neither — 8 C.F.R. § 103.3(a)(1)(ii) says an unfavorable decision "may" be appealed — so a petitioner can generally sue under the APA without first appealing. The exception is EB-5, where the statute requires an administrative appeal of an I-526 or regional-center denial before any court has jurisdiction. This is why sequencing is a deliberate choice, not a fixed track.

When It Fits

When this remedy is the right tool

Motion to reconsider — the denial got the law wrong

The officer misapplied a legal standard on the record already in front of them (for example, a Kazarian Step-1/Step-2 error), and no new evidence is needed to show it.

A motion to reconsider is the surgical tool for a pure legal error. It is decided on the existing record by the same office, which makes it fast and inexpensive — but also means you are asking the officer who denied you to agree they were wrong. Where the legal error is clear and the record is complete, this is often the efficient first move; where it is not, an AAO appeal or a federal suit may be the better forum for the same argument.

Motion to reopen — there is new evidence

New facts or documents exist that were not in the original record, or a denial resulted from an address or RFE-response failure rather than the merits.

A motion to reopen is the path when the problem is the record, not the reasoning. Because a federal court cannot take new evidence, reopening (or appealing, which also accepts new evidence) is the correct route whenever the fix is more or better documentation. New evidence must still show eligibility as of the original filing date.

AAO appeal — you want full de novo review with new evidence

The case needs both a fresh look at the law and the ability to add to the record, and a neutral reviewer above the service center is worth the wait.

The I-290B appeal is the broadest single bite inside the agency: de novo on law, fact, and discretion, with new evidence allowed. It is slower than a motion and its breadth can backfire, but a thorough appeal both maximizes the chance of an in-agency reversal and builds a clean record that strengthens a later APA challenge if the AAO also gets it wrong.

Skip to federal court — the legal error is clear and the record is complete

The denial rests on a clean legal error, no new evidence is needed, and another trip through the same agency is unlikely to be faster or fairer.

Because the AAO is not mandatory for most petitions, a petitioner with a strong legal-error case and a complete record can file an APA suit without appealing first. Going straight to a neutral federal forum can be the better move where the in-agency options would only delay the inevitable. Whether to do this — or to appeal first and sue only if the AAO affirms — is the central sequencing question we work through with you.

Timeline

What to expect when

  • The 30-day clock (33 if mailed) runs from the date of the denial for a motion or appeal; a revocation appeal is a tighter 15 days (18 if mailed). Missing these windows forfeits the in-agency options even though a later APA suit may still be available.
  • A timely appeal is first reviewed by the deciding office, which can reverse and approve within an initial 45-day window before the record is forwarded to the AAO — so a strong appeal sometimes resolves quickly at the service center.
  • The AAO's goal is to decide an appeal within 180 days of receiving the complete record, and its processing-times page reports how often it met that goal last quarter (see "How long does an I-290B take?" above). The deciding office's review comes first. Federal litigation timelines run in parallel to none of this and are a separate track.
  • An untimely appeal that meets the standard for a motion is treated as a motion and decided on the merits — but do not rely on that safety net; file within the deadline.
Risks & Limits

The honest downside

  • A motion asks the same office to reverse itself. Reconsideration and reopening go back to the officer or center that denied you; the psychology of asking for a reversal is not favorable, and outcomes are mixed. Where a decision-maker's independence matters, an AAO appeal or a federal court may be the better forum.
  • The AAO's de novo breadth cuts both ways. The AAO can affirm on a new ground the service center never raised and can revisit a criterion that was previously conceded. A weak point that survived the first decision is not safe on appeal.
  • Unlawful presence keeps accruing during an appeal. An AAO appeal does not toll unlawful presence. A beneficiary in the United States on a denied change or extension should weigh the immigration consequences of a long appeal against a faster alternative.
  • Appealing is not always required — and not always wise. For most petitions the AAO is optional. An appeal adds the deciding office's review and then the AAO's own, which it aims to finish within 180 days of receiving the record, and few appeals are sustained on the merits. If an appeal is unlikely to succeed, that time can simply delay a federal suit. The sequencing decision should be made deliberately, not by default.
A Note From the Firm

What we tell clients

The right response to a denial is rarely obvious, and the choice among a motion, an appeal, and a lawsuit is where much of the value of counsel actually sits. We look at why the petition was denied — bad facts or bad law — how much time is left on the 30-day clock, whether new evidence exists, and whether your forum is friendly, and then we recommend a sequence, not a reflex. Sometimes that is a quick motion to reconsider; sometimes it is a straight shot to federal court; often it is an appeal built to double as the foundation for litigation if the AAO affirms.

This page describes how post-denial motions and appeals generally work and how they fit a litigation strategy. It is general information, not legal advice about your case and not a prediction of any outcome. The right path depends on the language of your denial, the state of the record, the deadlines you face, and your goals — and it is a decision we make with you, case by case.

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to Get Started?

Tell us about your immigration needs and we'll be in touch to discuss how we can help.

Immigration counsel to Fortune 500 employers at a national firm · Adjudicated 12,000+ visas at the U.S. Consulate, Mexico · Working in U.S. immigration since 2008 Featured in Newsweek, Condé Nast Traveler, Daily Mail

Request a ConsultationCall